The understanding that fine mesh sieving is the optimal procedure for the recovery of minute finds poses two challenges for archeologists of historical periods: it is costly and time consuming, and it puts into question the value of data collected in excavations where sieving was conducted minimally or not at all. That hand picking causes loss of data pertaining to microfaunal remains is indisputable, but the extent of information loss regarding larger fauna is not as clear. In order to evaluate these challenges for macrofaunal remains, we carried out, for the first time, a comprehensive sieving experiment at Tel Dor, a multi-layered complex site, the most prominent site type in historical periods. We examine the effects of wet sieving on the macro- and microfauna frequencies, and discuss its implications in terms of the interpretations of the faunal assemblages and the choice of excavations' collection protocols. We demonstrate that while sieving has a substantial effect on microfauna frequencies, it has a limited effect on those of the macrofauna. We also suggest that faunal assemblages of livestock animals that were hand collected or partially sieved, are valid for comparison with sieved assemblages. Finally, we call for an explicit presentation of the retrieval protocol in site reports and other studies, differentiating clearly between sieved and un-sieved material, and raise some points for future discussion.
Bibliographical noteFunding Information:
We thank Guy Bar-Oz for discussion and comments on earlier drafts of this paper. We thank the area supervisors, Elisabeth Bloch-Smith, Sarah Culpepper Stroup and Yiftah Shalev for their collaboration and help throughout the excavation; and David Hadash and Anuar Zidane for their dedicated technical help during the field micro-picking. The research was funded by the Israel Science Foundation (Grant 1010/06). Sapir-Hen was also supported by an Ancient Israel scholarship of the Department of Archaeology and Ancient Near Eastern Cultures at Tel Aviv University.
© 2017 Elsevier Ltd
- Collection method
- Tel Dor
ASJC Scopus subject areas