We Are All in this Life Together

Research output: Contribution to journalArticlepeer-review


Many people find themselves ruminating on the existence of others, and wishing that they had not been born. This may come about innocently enough, as when one is stuck in traffic and laments that there are so many other drivers on the road to where one is intending to go; but also exists in more ominous form, when people wish that whole groups had not been born or, at least, had not been in one’s vicinity: the poor or the rich, immigrants or locals, people of a certain ethnicity or religion. I call these thoughts "preferences for others' nonexistence" (PON). I show that the Nonidentity problem or effect by and large excludes PON thoughts, showing them to be (given plausible assumptions) irrational, and indeed self-defeating. The self is held hostage by the other. We come to exist together, or not at all.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)85-93
Number of pages9
Journalעיון: רבעון פילוסופי
StatePublished - Jan 2020


Dive into the research topics of 'We Are All in this Life Together'. Together they form a unique fingerprint.

Cite this