TY - JOUR
T1 - High Genetic Diagnostic Yield for Patients with Rare Movement Disorders at a Single-Center Neurogenetics Clinic
AU - Penn, Dvir
AU - Amir, Yam
AU - David, Gil Ben
AU - Kuralop, Alina
AU - Barel, Dalit
AU - Hamiel, Uri
AU - Bach, Michal
AU - Elhanan, Emil
AU - Barkan, Tali
AU - Marom, Daphna
AU - Mory, Adi
AU - Simantov, Noga
AU - Eshed, Gadi Maayan
AU - Faust-Socher, Achinoam
AU - Livneh, Vered
AU - Thaler, Avner
AU - Omer, Nurit
AU - Shiner, Tamara
AU - Giladi, Nir
AU - Gurevich, Tanya
AU - Feldman, Hagit Baris
AU - Alcalay, Roy N.
AU - Yaron, Yuval
AU - Ponger, Penina
N1 - Publisher Copyright:
© 2025 The Author(s). Movement Disorders Clinical Practice published by Wiley Periodicals LLC on behalf of International Parkinson and Movement Disorder Society.
PY - 2025/6/5
Y1 - 2025/6/5
N2 - Background: As advanced molecular testing is incorporated into routine clinical practice, accessibility and yield remain limited. Objectives: We propose a simplified and effective workup strategy to maximize diagnostic yield based on presented diagnostic yield of rare movement disorders at a tertiary Neurogenetics Clinic. Methods: Retrospective analysis (2019–2023) of 190 patients aged 2–87 years, diagnosed with cerebellar ataxia (CA, n = 91), hereditary spastic paraparesis (HSP, n = 51), or dystonia and paroxysmal dyskinesia movement disorders (DPD, n = 48). Workup included next-generation sequencing (NGS) and repeat expansion testing. Undiagnosed cases underwent exome or genome sequencing (ES/GS). Results: Among 190 patients, 38 had a prior genetic diagnosis, and 106 were undiagnosed patients who pursued workup; 43 of 106 (41%) cases were genetically diagnosed: 25 of 43(58%) by NGS, 13 of 43 (30%) by repeat expansion analysis, and 5 of 43(12%) by sequencing for founder mutation or target gene. Diagnostic rate in the newly diagnosed CA subgroup reached 52%, 30% in HSP and 32% in DPD. In the overall cohort, the diagnostic yield of NGS panels was 31% and 33% for ES. Diagnostic yield was significantly higher (P-value<0.05) among patients with early-onset disease or isolated phenotypes. Conclusions: We report a high diagnostic yield (41%) compared to reported literature (20%–30%), especially in patients with early-onset disease. ES, compared to panel testing, was of greater contribution to diagnosis of complex phenotypes. Our findings argue for early referral to genetic workup, suggesting that tailored workup based on phenotype complexity and age of onset can reduce auxiliary testing. Further cost–benefit analysis is required to lower expenses and ensure timely diagnosis.
AB - Background: As advanced molecular testing is incorporated into routine clinical practice, accessibility and yield remain limited. Objectives: We propose a simplified and effective workup strategy to maximize diagnostic yield based on presented diagnostic yield of rare movement disorders at a tertiary Neurogenetics Clinic. Methods: Retrospective analysis (2019–2023) of 190 patients aged 2–87 years, diagnosed with cerebellar ataxia (CA, n = 91), hereditary spastic paraparesis (HSP, n = 51), or dystonia and paroxysmal dyskinesia movement disorders (DPD, n = 48). Workup included next-generation sequencing (NGS) and repeat expansion testing. Undiagnosed cases underwent exome or genome sequencing (ES/GS). Results: Among 190 patients, 38 had a prior genetic diagnosis, and 106 were undiagnosed patients who pursued workup; 43 of 106 (41%) cases were genetically diagnosed: 25 of 43(58%) by NGS, 13 of 43 (30%) by repeat expansion analysis, and 5 of 43(12%) by sequencing for founder mutation or target gene. Diagnostic rate in the newly diagnosed CA subgroup reached 52%, 30% in HSP and 32% in DPD. In the overall cohort, the diagnostic yield of NGS panels was 31% and 33% for ES. Diagnostic yield was significantly higher (P-value<0.05) among patients with early-onset disease or isolated phenotypes. Conclusions: We report a high diagnostic yield (41%) compared to reported literature (20%–30%), especially in patients with early-onset disease. ES, compared to panel testing, was of greater contribution to diagnosis of complex phenotypes. Our findings argue for early referral to genetic workup, suggesting that tailored workup based on phenotype complexity and age of onset can reduce auxiliary testing. Further cost–benefit analysis is required to lower expenses and ensure timely diagnosis.
KW - cerebellar ataxia
KW - dystonia
KW - hereditary spastic paraparesis
KW - Neurogenetics
KW - paroxysmal dyskinesia
UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=105007299169&partnerID=8YFLogxK
U2 - 10.1002/mdc3.70145
DO - 10.1002/mdc3.70145
M3 - Article
C2 - 40470849
AN - SCOPUS:105007299169
SN - 2330-1619
JO - Movement Disorders Clinical Practice
JF - Movement Disorders Clinical Practice
ER -