TY - JOUR
T1 - Correlation between stillbirth vital statistics and medical records
AU - Heuser, Cara C.
AU - Hunn, Jessica
AU - Varner, Michael
AU - Hossain, Shaheen
AU - Vered, Shiraz
AU - Silver, Robert M.
PY - 2010/12
Y1 - 2010/12
N2 - Objective: Most data regarding conditions associated with or contributing to stillbirth are derived from fetal death certificates. Our purposes were to compare stillbirth data recorded in vital statistics with those in the medical record and to investigate whether diagnostic evaluations differed in tertiary care and community hospitals. Methods: In this cross-sectional study, fetal death certificate data identified individuals with stillbirths delivering in eight Salt Lake City hospitals from 1998 to 2002. Medical records were reviewed to assess demographics, diagnostic evaluation, and potential causes of stillbirth. Data were compared between death certificates and the medical record by calculation of the κ coefficient for categorical variables or Kendall's τ-b coefficients based on the number of concordant and discordant pairs of observations for continuous variables. Diagnostic tests completed were compared between community and tertiary care hospitals with χ or Fisher exact test. Results: Five-hundred fifty-six individuals were identified, and 461 (83%) charts were available for review. Correlation between death certificates and the medical record was nearly perfect for demographic variables (correlation 0.8-0.9) but slight to moderate (correlation 0.2-0.5) for contributing or etiologic factors. Important diagnostic tests performed significantly more often in tertiary care than community hospitals included autopsy (35% compared with 13%, P<.01), karyotype (17% compared with 4%, P<.01), Kleihauer-Betke (22% compared with 13%, P=.01), toxicology screen (13% compared with 2%, P<.01), and complete blood count (95% compared with 90%, P=.03). Conclusion: There are important discrepancies between fetal death certificates and medical records. Complete work-up, review of the medical record, and efforts to increase accurate reporting may improve the accuracy of stillbirth vital statistics. Diagnostic evaluation was more extensive in tertiary care hospitals.
AB - Objective: Most data regarding conditions associated with or contributing to stillbirth are derived from fetal death certificates. Our purposes were to compare stillbirth data recorded in vital statistics with those in the medical record and to investigate whether diagnostic evaluations differed in tertiary care and community hospitals. Methods: In this cross-sectional study, fetal death certificate data identified individuals with stillbirths delivering in eight Salt Lake City hospitals from 1998 to 2002. Medical records were reviewed to assess demographics, diagnostic evaluation, and potential causes of stillbirth. Data were compared between death certificates and the medical record by calculation of the κ coefficient for categorical variables or Kendall's τ-b coefficients based on the number of concordant and discordant pairs of observations for continuous variables. Diagnostic tests completed were compared between community and tertiary care hospitals with χ or Fisher exact test. Results: Five-hundred fifty-six individuals were identified, and 461 (83%) charts were available for review. Correlation between death certificates and the medical record was nearly perfect for demographic variables (correlation 0.8-0.9) but slight to moderate (correlation 0.2-0.5) for contributing or etiologic factors. Important diagnostic tests performed significantly more often in tertiary care than community hospitals included autopsy (35% compared with 13%, P<.01), karyotype (17% compared with 4%, P<.01), Kleihauer-Betke (22% compared with 13%, P=.01), toxicology screen (13% compared with 2%, P<.01), and complete blood count (95% compared with 90%, P=.03). Conclusion: There are important discrepancies between fetal death certificates and medical records. Complete work-up, review of the medical record, and efforts to increase accurate reporting may improve the accuracy of stillbirth vital statistics. Diagnostic evaluation was more extensive in tertiary care hospitals.
UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=78650153324&partnerID=8YFLogxK
U2 - 10.1097/AOG.0b013e3181fb8838
DO - 10.1097/AOG.0b013e3181fb8838
M3 - Article
C2 - 21099594
AN - SCOPUS:78650153324
SN - 0029-7844
VL - 116
SP - 1296
EP - 1301
JO - Obstetrics and Gynecology
JF - Obstetrics and Gynecology
IS - 6
ER -
