A meta-analysis of psychodynamic treatments for borderline and cluster C personality disorders

John R. Keefe, Shelley F. McMain, Kevin S. McCarthy, Sigal Zilcha-Mano, Ulrike Dinger, Zeynep Sahin, Kathryn Graham, Jacques P. Barber

Research output: Contribution to journalArticlepeer-review

Abstract

Personality disorders (PD) carry high psychosocial dysfunction and are associated with treatment resistance in nonspecialized care. Psychodynamic therapies (PDT) are often used to treat PDs, but there has never been a systematic meta-analysis of PDT trials for PD. To evaluate the evidence base for PDTs for PDs across multiple outcome domain, a systematic search for PDT for PD trials was conducted through PubMed and PsycINFO. Sixteen trials were identified, comprising 19 dynamic, 8 active, and 9 control groups predominantly reflecting treatment of borderline and mixed Cluster C PDs, and a random effects meta-analysis was undertaken. PDTs were superior to controls in improving core PD symptoms (g = -0.63; 95% confidence interval [CI; -0.87, -0.41]), suicidality (g = -0.79, p = .02; 95% CI [-1.38, -0.20]), general psychiatric symptoms (g = -0.47; 95% CI [-0.69, -0.25]), and functioning (g = -0.66; 95% CI [-1.01, -0.32]), but not for interpersonal problems due to heterogeneity (g=-1.25; 95% CI [-3.22, 0.71]). Outcomes for PDTs were not different from other active treatments in core PD (g = 0.05; 95% CI [-0.25, 0.35]) or other symptoms. This pattern continued into posttreatment follow-up (average 14 months). Study quality was generally rated as adequate and was unrelated to outcomes. Compared with other treatments, PDTs do not have different acute effects and are superior to controls, although only trials treating BPD employed active controls and non-BPD trials were of lower quality. Underresearched areas include narcissistic PD, specific Cluster C disorders, and personality pathology as a continuous construct.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)157-169
Number of pages13
JournalPersonality Disorders: Theory, Research, and Treatment
Volume11
Issue number3
DOIs
StatePublished - May 2020

Bibliographical note

Funding Information:
John R. Keefe is supported by National Institutes of Health/National Center for Advancing Translational Sciences Grant TL1-TR-002386 through the Clinical and Translational Science Center at Weill Medical College of Cornell University.

Publisher Copyright:
© 2019 American Psychological Association.

Keywords

  • Meta-analysis
  • Outcome research
  • Personality disorder
  • Psychodynamic therapy

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Clinical Psychology
  • Psychiatry and Mental health

Fingerprint

Dive into the research topics of 'A meta-analysis of psychodynamic treatments for borderline and cluster C personality disorders'. Together they form a unique fingerprint.

Cite this